IMPOSIBIL DE LICHIDAT – TMB a mentinut sentinta judecatoarei Raluca Focsa de la JS1, care a respins cererea de dizolvare si lichidare a UNBR-Bota: "Nu se poate solicita constatarea nulitatii absolute a unor institutii, ci doar a actelor juridice care au stat la baza infiintarii lor... UNBR-Bota a fost infiintata prin hotarare judecatoreasca si nu poate fi introdusa o actiune prin care sa se constate nulitatea acestei institutii fara a se aduce atingere hotararii care a infiintat-o" (Sentinta)
Sectia a IV-a civila a Tribunalului Bucuresti a stabilit, printr-o decizie definitiva pronuntata la jumatatea lunii trecute, ca Uniunea Nationala a Barourilor din Romania condusa de avocatul Pompiliu Bota (foto) nu poate fi dizolvata si lichidata, intrucat a fost infiintata in baza unei hotarari judecatoresti, a carei desfiintare nu este posibila in afara cailor de atac stabilite de lege. Este vorba despre Decizia civila nr. 1.326/19.12.2014, pronuntata in dosarul nr. 54430/299/2012 avand ca obiect dizolvare societate si lichidare cabinet de avocat, prin care a fost mentinuta Sentinta nr. 23.582/05.12.2013 a Judecatoriei Sectorului 1:
„Respinge apelul ca nefondat. Admite cererea de interventie in interesul intimatilor-parati Cabinet individual de avocat Ion Tudoran Alexandru si Uniunea Nationala a Barourilor din Romania. Cu recurs in 15 zile de la comunicare. Pronuntata azi, 19.12.2014, in sedinta publica”. Decizia Sectiei a IV-a civile a Tribunalului Bucuresti nu este irevocabila, insa sansele ca instanta civila de recurs sa intoarca solutia din fond si apel sunt aproape nule.
In prima instanta, judecatoarea Raluca Focsa de la JS1 a respins ca inadmisibila cererea de chemare in judecata formulata de o societate comerciala impotriva unui avocat „constitutional” si a UNBR-Bota. Mai exact, firma Terradox Solutions SRL a solicitat Judecatoriei Sectorului 1 "sa constate si sa dispuna nulitatea Cabinetului Individual de Avocatura 'Ion Tudoran Alexandru' si, pe cale de consecinta, sa dispuna dizolvarea si lichidarea acestuia, sa constate nulitatea codului de identificare fiscala nr. 27145178 atribuit Cabinetului Individual de Avocatura 'Ion Tudoran Alexandru', sa constate nulitatea Uniunii Nationale a Barourilor din Romania (Baroul Bota) si, pe cale de consecinta, sa dispuna dizolvarea si lichidarea acestei parate".
Iata ce a statuat prima instanta prin Sentinta civila nr. 23.582 din 5 decembrie 2013, solutie mentinuta de TMB prin Decizia definitiva nr. 1.326 din 19 decembrie 2014:
„In ceea ce priveste constatarea nulitatii Cabinetului Individual de Avocat Ion Tudoran Alexandru si a Uniunii Nationale a Barourilor din Romania (Baroul Bota), instanta retine ca aceste cereri sunt inadmisibile, reclamanta avand posibilitatea de a formula o actiune in realizare in raport cu actele care au stat la baza infiintarii celor doua entitati. Nu se poate solicita constatarea nulitatii absolute a unor institutii, ci doar a actelor juridice care au stat la baza infiintarii lor. De asemenea, nu se poate constata nulitatea unor institutii, iar actele in baza carora au fost infiintate sa ramana valabile. Dupa cum a aratat chiar reclamanta, Uniunea Nationala a Barourilor din Romania (Baroul Bota) a fost infiintata prin hotarare judecatoreasca si nu poate fi introdusa o actiune prin care sa se constate nulitatea acestei institutii fara a se aduce atingere hotararii judecatoresti care a infiintat-o si care nu poate fi atacata decat potrivit cailor stabilite de lege. (...)
In ceea ce priveste capatul de cerere referitor la constatarea nulitatii codului de identificare fiscala nr. 27145178 atribuit Cabinetului Individual de Avocat Ion Tudoran Alexandru, instanta are in vedere prevederile art. 77 alin. 2 din OG 92/2003 care stipuleaza ca, la incetarea conditiilor care au generat inregistrarea fiscala, contribuabilii au obligatia de a preda organelor fiscale, in vederea anularii certificatului de inregistrarea fiscala, odata cu depunerea declaratiei de mentiuni. Rezulta ca se poate dispune anularea certificatului de inregistrare fiscala, iar nu direct a codului de identificare fiscala, insa doar in situatia incetarii conditiilor care au generat inregistrarea fiscala, incetare care nu poate fi generata doar in sensul celor retinute mai sus cu privire la celelalte capete de cerere, astfel ca nu poate fi ceruta direct constatarea nulitatii codului de identificare fiscala. Din aceste considerente, instanta apreciaza ca formularea unei actiuni in constatare in sensul aspectelor solicitate de reclamanta este inadmisibila, motiv pentru care va admite exceptia si va respinge cele patru capete de cerere ale cererii de chemare in judecata, astfel cum a fost completata si precizata, ca inadmisibile.”
Adauga comentariu
DISCLAIMER
Atentie! Postati pe propria raspundere!
Inainte de a posta, cititi aici regulamentul: Termeni legali si Conditii
Comentarii
# Ultimul Charlot
19 January 2015 17:41
+11
# ,,e manevră,,
19 January 2015 19:20
-7
# Catalin Racaceanu
20 January 2015 09:20
+1
# AVOCATI CAUTAM COLABORATORI CU/FARA EXPERIENTA
26 January 2015 10:02
+1
# Alex
19 January 2015 17:43
+14
# procurorul sucevean
19 January 2015 18:05
+5
# judecator
19 January 2015 17:51
+5
# alt judecator
20 January 2015 09:57
+4
# BERCEA MONDIAL : ,, e manevra lu frații miei...........,,.
19 January 2015 17:52
0
# Cornel
19 January 2015 17:55
0
# Adrian
19 January 2015 18:13
+7
# Liviu
19 January 2015 18:14
0
# Monte Cristo
19 January 2015 18:43
+6
# Nik
19 January 2015 19:25
+8
# bella
19 January 2015 19:06
+8
# GUY FAWKES
20 January 2015 15:14
0
# Adina
19 January 2015 19:15
+2
# Bogy
19 January 2015 19:33
+3
# bella
19 January 2015 19:38
-4
# Ultimul Charlot
19 January 2015 21:54
+3
# gelu
19 January 2015 21:01
+5
# bella
19 January 2015 21:51
-3
# GUY FAWKES
19 January 2015 22:41
0
# oarecare
20 January 2015 00:03
0
# GUY FAWKES
20 January 2015 13:33
+2
Citeza pe oarecare
# ooo
20 January 2015 14:21
+3
# bella
20 January 2015 05:42
+2
# avocat traditional
20 January 2015 13:38
+4
# bella
20 January 2015 15:06
+3
# Adam
20 January 2015 18:27
-2
# Garip
20 January 2015 19:04
-2
# Av. Popa T. Nicolae - Baroul Tulcea - UNBR (Bota)
20 January 2015 21:43
-2
# Av. Popa T. Nicolae - Baroul Tulcea - UNBR (Bota)
21 January 2015 21:40
0
# 992
22 January 2015 11:01
+6
# bella
22 January 2015 13:36
+4
# Berti
22 January 2015 17:02
0
# Catalin Racaceanu
22 January 2015 17:33
0
# oare
22 January 2015 17:45
0
# Berti
22 January 2015 18:45
0
# Av. Popa T. Nicolae - Baroul Tulcea - UNBR (Bota)
22 January 2015 18:23
0
# Piki
22 January 2015 22:38
+2
# descatusare
22 January 2015 22:48
0
# bella
23 January 2015 08:59
0
# Berti
23 January 2015 11:46
0
# unul
25 January 2015 12:11
0
# oare
23 January 2015 13:12
0
# Berti
23 January 2015 14:08
0
# oare
23 January 2015 15:18
0
# Berti
23 January 2015 18:29
0
# bella
23 January 2015 13:14
0
# Berti
23 January 2015 14:22
0
# guy fawkes
23 January 2015 15:52
0
# Berti
23 January 2015 18:17
0
# GUY FAWKES
23 January 2015 21:06
0
# Berti
23 January 2015 22:04
+1
# GUY FAWEKS
23 January 2015 22:18
-1
# EMA
24 January 2015 09:40
-1
# bota!
23 January 2015 14:48
-1
# @berti
23 January 2015 15:01
-1
# oare
23 January 2015 16:39
0
# Berti
23 January 2015 18:03
+2
# BI
24 January 2015 12:40
0
# GUY FAWKES
24 January 2015 14:41
-1
# oarecare
24 January 2015 18:25
-1
# oare k are
24 January 2015 19:12
-1
# oarecare
24 January 2015 21:36
0
# UNBR Bota
25 January 2015 09:34
+1
# GUY FAWKES
25 January 2015 11:18
0
# oarecare
25 January 2015 13:09
0
# oare k re
26 January 2015 12:17
0
# Monte Cristo
24 January 2015 15:13
0
# Lena
24 January 2015 12:57
+1
# saracu B I
24 January 2015 15:45
+1
# crustaceu
24 January 2015 21:28
-2
# ION
25 January 2015 12:38
+2
# Iona
25 January 2015 17:34
0
# Gxg Low
27 January 2015 12:50
0
# Catalin Racaceanu
27 January 2015 13:10
+1
# Hegel
25 January 2015 17:50
-1
# O nou Revolutie
26 January 2015 21:16
0
# Costinel
29 January 2015 10:07
0
# oarecare
29 January 2015 13:52
0
# OARE K RE
29 January 2015 14:57
0
# Gxg Low
27 January 2015 12:53
0
# bella
27 January 2015 14:33
0
# nedumerit .
27 January 2015 14:33
0
# nedumerit ?
27 January 2015 14:49
0
# bella
27 January 2015 14:59
0
# Pico Bellllo
27 January 2015 19:38
0
# bella
27 January 2015 15:09
0
# Dana
27 January 2015 15:45
0
# Dana
27 January 2015 15:49
+1
# Dan
27 January 2015 17:34
+2
# rasella
27 January 2015 18:39
0
# bella
27 January 2015 19:05
0
# 2004
27 January 2015 19:59
0
# Inter
27 January 2015 20:35
-1
# florea dixit
27 January 2015 22:33
0
# Catalin Racaceanu
28 January 2015 13:40
0
# Inter
28 January 2015 15:25
0
# Nik
27 January 2015 22:50
0
# Catalin Racaceanu
28 January 2015 07:57
0
# bella
27 January 2015 21:05
0
# bella
27 January 2015 21:13
0
# bella
28 January 2015 05:52
0
# bella
28 January 2015 08:16
0
# oarecare
28 January 2015 09:11
0
# bella
28 January 2015 10:31
0
# oarecare
28 January 2015 11:00
0
# florea dixit
28 January 2015 11:16
0
# bella
28 January 2015 11:53
0
# bella
28 January 2015 12:04
0
# oarecare
28 January 2015 12:36
0
# bella
28 January 2015 12:54
0
# oarecare
28 January 2015 13:52
0
# BI
28 January 2015 13:35
0
# Bai BI si restu
28 January 2015 15:31
+1
# bombardier
30 January 2015 16:32
0
# Face
28 January 2015 15:33
+1
# Alex
28 January 2015 15:39
0
# oarecare
28 January 2015 15:42
-1
# mai taie
28 January 2015 17:00
0
# chiar ca esti un oarecare
28 January 2015 17:05
0
# Sandu
28 January 2015 17:30
+2
# oarecare
29 January 2015 10:03
+2
# Bun
30 January 2015 11:53
-1
# DOREL
30 January 2015 14:18
0
# bella
30 January 2015 14:51
0
# DOREL PENTRU BELLA
30 January 2015 15:09
0